The GOAT debate between LeBron James and Michael Jordan has been going on forever, and it probably isn’t ending anytime soon. Let me make one thing clear before we start: Michael Jordan is one of the greatest basketball players ever. Having LeBron ahead of him does not mean I think Jordan wasn’t incredible.
But when I look at their entire careers, everything they could do on a basketball court, the situations they succeeded in and how long they remained great, I have LeBron James as the greatest basketball player of all time.
Here is why.
Winning With Three Different Franchises
One of the biggest arguments for LeBron is something that doesn’t get enough appreciation. He won championships with three completely different organizations.
LeBron won two championships with the Miami Heat, returned to Cleveland and delivered the Cavaliers their first championship, then went to Los Angeles and won another championship with the Lakers. He didn’t just win with three franchises either. He was Finals MVP for all four championships, becoming the first player in NBA history to win Finals MVP with three different franchises.
Different teammates, different coaches, different systems and different organizations. Everywhere LeBron went, he proved he could reach the top.
Jordan’s six championships are incredible, and six championships in six Finals appearances will always be one of the strongest arguments for him. But all six came with the Chicago Bulls, alongside Scottie Pippen and with Phil Jackson as his head coach. LeBron proved he could win championships under several completely different circumstances.
The All Time Leading Scorer
LeBron James is the NBA’s all time leading scorer, which is even crazier when you consider that scoring has never been the only thing that defines his game.
LeBron entered the league as one of the most gifted passers we had ever seen at his size. He has always been capable of controlling an offense as both a scorer and facilitator, yet he still eventually climbed above every player in NBA history in career points.
That represents what separates LeBron for me. He doesn’t have to dominate a basketball game in one way. He can score, create for everyone else, rebound, control the tempo and, particularly in his prime, defend multiple positions.
There have been better pure scorers, better pure passers and better pure rebounders. I don’t think there has ever been another player who combined everything at LeBron’s level for this long.
Longevity Matters
Sometimes longevity gets treated like it shouldn’t matter in the GOAT debate. I completely disagree.
Remaining one of the best basketball players in the world year after year is an accomplishment itself. LeBron has played more than two decades of NBA basketball and accumulated an unbelievable amount of mileage between regular seasons, playoffs, Finals runs and international basketball.
And his career didn’t simply consist of hanging around long enough to break records. He remained productive. Longevity isn’t just about how many seasons you played. It is about how long you remained capable of playing at an elite level.
LeBron’s combination of peak performance and longevity is something we may never see again.
What About Clutch?
One of the arguments I have heard throughout LeBron’s career is that Michael Jordan was clutch while LeBron wasn’t. The numbers make that narrative very difficult for me to accept.
When facing elimination in the playoffs, LeBron has averaged 33.5 points, 10.4 rebounds and 7.5 assists per game. Jordan averaged 31.3 points per game in elimination games. When your team’s entire season is on the line, it is difficult to find a more pressure-filled situation than that.
Then there are the actual game-winners. LeBron has hit five playoff buzzer-beating game-winning shots during his career. Think about that: five separate times in the postseason, LeBron took the shot with the game on the line and ended it at the buzzer.
And being clutch isn’t limited to making the final shot. One of the greatest examples came in Game 7 of the 2016 NBA Finals. With the score tied late in the fourth quarter, LeBron chased down Andre Iguodala and produced one of the most famous defensive plays in NBA history.
Jordan absolutely deserves his reputation as one of the greatest clutch performers ever. I am not trying to take that away from him. But the idea that Jordan was clutch while LeBron somehow wasn’t simply doesn’t hold up.
LeBron has delivered game-winners, historic elimination-game performances and championship-saving plays throughout his career. Pressure situations are not a weakness in his GOAT case. If anything, they strengthen it.
The Jordan Argument Needs Context Too
One of the most common arguments in Jordan’s favor is simple: 6-0. Six Finals appearances and six championships. That’s incredible.
But basketball careers cannot be reduced to one Finals record.
Before Scottie Pippen arrived in Chicago, Jordan’s Bulls went 1-9 in playoff games. That doesn’t mean Jordan was the problem. He was already producing unbelievable individual performances. It demonstrates something much simpler: even Michael Jordan needed a great team around him to win.
Jordan never won a championship without Pippen, and he never won a championship without Phil Jackson as his head coach.
Again, that isn’t an insult. Every champion needs help. But if we’re going to criticize LeBron for playing with great teammates or needing the right pieces around him, we have to apply that context to everybody. Jordan wasn’t winning championships by himself either.
The 2016 Championship
If I had to choose one accomplishment that summarizes LeBron’s case, it might be 2016.
Cleveland faced a Golden State Warriors team that had won 73 regular season games. The Cavaliers fell behind 3-1 in the NBA Finals, and no team had ever come back from a 3-1 deficit to win the Finals.
LeBron and Cleveland did it.
They completed the comeback by winning Game 7 in Golden State, ending Cleveland’s 52-year major professional sports championship drought and giving the Cavaliers the first NBA championship in franchise history.
When discussing LeBron’s legacy, that title has to carry enormous weight.
Versatility
This might ultimately be the biggest reason I choose LeBron.
If I were building the perfect basketball player, I would want someone who could score at an elite level, run an offense, create for teammates, rebound, defend multiple positions, attack the rim, play in transition and adjust his game depending on what his team needed.
That sounds a lot like LeBron James.
We’ve watched different versions of him throughout his career: the explosive young Cleveland LeBron, the physically overwhelming Miami LeBron, the complete veteran superstar who returned to Cleveland and the older LeBron who continued adapting his game as his athleticism naturally declined.
His game evolved, but his impact remained.
Why LeBron Is The GOAT
Michael Jordan has an incredible case: six championships, six Finals MVPs, five regular season MVPs, ten scoring titles and one of the greatest peaks basketball has ever seen. If somebody tells me Jordan is their GOAT, I’m not going to tell them they’re crazy.
I simply value LeBron’s total body of work more.
Four championships. Four Finals MVPs. Championships with three different franchises. The only player to win Finals MVP with three different franchises. The NBA’s all time leading scorer. More than 10,000 career rebounds and assists. Ten NBA Finals appearances. Eight consecutive Finals appearances. Five playoff buzzer-beating game-winners. And elite basketball spanning more than two decades.
Jordan reached a level almost nobody in basketball history has ever touched. LeBron reached that level too, then sustained greatness across different teams, teammates, coaches and eras for a length of time that I find impossible to ignore.
That’s why, when I have to choose one player as the greatest basketball player of all time, my answer is LeBron James.
The GOAT debate will continue forever. For me, though, the King sits at number one.
If you enjoyed the article, make sure to leave a like and subscribe to Ethical Sports Takes for more NBA discussions, rankings and stories.
Leave a Reply